Hiring the wrong roofer can cost thousands in repairs, delays, and stress. Industry experts share the most common warning signs to help homeowners avoid scams and poor workmanship.
If you've ever had roof damage after a storm, you know how quickly "help" can appear at your door. Unfortunately, not every contractor offering assistance is qualified or even legitimate. In fact, roofing contractor fraud spikes after major weather events, and spotting the red flags early can save you from costly mistakes.
According to a nationwide myClearInsights Hub survey, 67% of homeowners say online reviews are "very" or "extremely" important when choosing a roofer, and 35% name them the single most important factor. A will typically have at least 40 verifiable reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, Nextdoor, or the BBB, with photos and consistent feedback.
Over 41% of homeowners rank professional licensing as a critical hiring factor. Always request proof of state licensing and both liability and workers' compensation insurance. Failure to provide these is the most-cited red flag in multiple industry guides.
Legitimate roofers won't demand an immediate decision. Be wary of anyone creating false urgency or pushing you to sign on the spot.
While a deposit is normal, demands for full payment before work starts should raise concerns.
Many scams start this way. Experts recommend verifying the company's local presence before agreeing to any work.
Get every detail in writing—materials, labor, timelines, and costs.
No website, no local address, and no track record? That's a red flag.
Cross-check reviews across multiple platforms for consistency.
Overpromising is often a sign corners will be cut.
Reputable roofers can show proof of past work in your area.
Missed calls, unclear answers, and late arrivals can signal bigger issues down the line.
Local roofing professionals, such as Galveston County Roofing in Texas, note that certification from major manufacturers (like GAF) is another trust marker. These certifications require proof of licensing, insurance, and a solid BBB record.
"Homeowners should also insist on a detailed written contract and after-work warranty," their team advises.
A legitimate roofing company will welcome your questions, provide documentation without hesitation, and have a track record of satisfied clients in your area.
If you're unsure about a contractor, consult a for a roof inspection before committing to any work. It's a small step that could save you thousands—and give you peace of mind that your home is in qualified hands.
